Worldwide International Attempts

Paris Metro

There used to be a website at www.metrochallenge.tk where someone had detailed an attempt that took them just over 13 hours - this website does not appear to be 'up' at the moment though.

But better than that time is an account at http://l-homme.net/runderground/ where it's been done in 9 hours, 53 minutes and 2 seconds, on the 6th May 2005. A very good time indeed.

 

The New York Subway

A website I found about some people who did the whole of the New York subway system.

 

Calgary Light Rail Transit (July 2005)

Scott Blair from Calgary, Canada - his cousin Colin and friend Blair did the Calgary CRT. It's technically a light rail rather than an underground/metro system. But they still wanted to do all of it and see how fast it could be done in.

Scott writes:

With only 36 stations, two lines and just change of trains required, I knew that this wasn't going to be very difficult, and as a result I did almost no planning in terms of the route we would take. The starting point was chosen rather arbitrarily, but I thought it would be best to end up in the northeast part of the city where Colin lives, and I would get back home from there. This would turn out to cause us a significant problem later on.

We got a ride to the southern most station Bridlewood/Somerset, and ran onto the platform and bought our tickets. The train was waiting there, and it set out a minute after we boarded at 11:07AM. The first five stations went really smoothly, and we averaged about 3 minutes between stops. It was then I first realized the whole thing would take a lot less time than the 3 hours I had predicted.

We had our first delay at the sixth station (Southland) when the train sat for about 90 seconds longer than usual as it waited for passengers from a connecting bus to get on. This would end up being the only delay for the entire run that was not our own fault.

In under 30 minutes we entered the downtown core, and had to contend with full trains, and some inquisitive people. I guess you don't usually see people on the train writing down times at every stop and taking photos of all the station names.

We got to the northwest end of the line at 12:01, which meant we had been through 22 stations in under an hour! We then had to back-track down the northwest leg to downtown and switch lines to the one that heads to the northeast part of the city. We ran the two blocks back the the 10th Street station, but we didn't really have to, as it is the terminus for that line and the train waited a few minutes before going back. As this was the only connection we had to make we decided to run it to make it seem more exciting.

We went back through downtown again, but stopped at different stations, as the east-bound trains use separate stations from the west-bound trains. Just as we pulled into the City Hall station Blair noticed a big flaw in our route. The 3rd Street S.E. station can only be reached by travelling west on a train from Whitehorn, but we were planning on riding the train directly up north to the end of that line, and would miss the station completely if we carried on. The other guys asked if we should get off at City Hall to try and catch the problem station, but just as we went for the doors to get off, the train pulled out, and we were stuck.

The other people on the train must have thought we were idiots as we moaned and complained about the big screw-up. We rode up one leg to the Bridgeland station, and got off and went back towards the city centre to pick up the 3rd Street station. We got off there, and walked back to the City Hall station to carry on back up to Whitehorn. From there it was a simple ride up to the end of the line where the train stopped at 1:04:04PM, giving us a total time to complete the system of 1hr 57min 4sec.

We lost 20 minutes by having to back-track the one leg, so if we had started at the Whitehorn station and finished at Bridlewood/Somerset, the whole thing could probably be done in under 100min. This also means that it could be done on one ticket for $2.00 if you cheated a bit. One ticket entitles you to any one-way journey within a 90 minute period. If we risked being slightly over time we could do it at half the cost (we ended up having to buy a second ticket at Bridgeland). Of course, if one wanted to risk it, you can ride the thing for free, because the LRT uses an honour system, and they only sporadically check for tickets as you exit the platform, or occasionally on the train. You could ride about 30-40 times for every time they actually ask for proof of purchase, but as law-abiding citizens we wouldn't do that.


Obviously because of the one major mistake, I am planning on making another attempt sometime soon. It is so easy compared to most other cities' train systems, it is no burden to try again. If it is done smoothly, and at the right time of day, it may be possible to complete all 36 stations in 95 minutes. I will have to find out.


Hamburg, Germany

A chap called Gunnar Thöle got in touch with me, as he's done 'The Challenge' for his hometown of Hamburg, Germany. You can read the complete story at his own webpage at: http://gabistapler.de/bahn/hvv but it is all in German!

Gunnar is a 26 years old engineering student from Hamburg, Germany who found out about the London Underground 'tube challenge' a few years ago on the internet.

Quick on the uptake, he transferred the tube quest to Hamburg (adapting the rules slightly in the process). The current record - made on Friday January the 30th 2004, was quite a cold day with heavy snowfall, and he made a time of 20 hours and 17 minutes for all of the 206 stations on the current 'USAR' map (starting in Neugraben at 04:30 and finishing in Wedel at 00:47 the next night). Click on the small version of the map here for a full sized version!

This first attempt was just a proof-of-concept, so there's still much room for improvement. He did it all by himself because all of his friends thought he went nuts, instead of supporting him!

206 stations only, you might ask, in such a long time? Well, the biggest difficulty with Hamburg is that there are a few stretches of overground railway on the official map (so they have to be visited), some of them only having an every-two-hour service or worse.

I talk to Gunnar some more, and we swap experiences of each others transport systems. Gunnar writes:

My limited experience of the London transport system was that it's generally OK, it transfered me from place to place just fine, and i haven't only been to the tourist places. I am a regular reader of the uk.transport.london usenet newsgroup (so that i don't forget my english skills) and from what i have read there the Hamburg system is much more reliable, yes.

I don't want to make you envy me, but I've never been on a failed train (but sometimes they do fail) for the 2 and a half years i'm living in Hamburg, i get a seat 99% of all trips made, I am seldom late, i've never been on a train that was turned short (but i know this has happened), there is a full timetable (i mean, exact arrival and departure times) for every train and bus which is kept to most of the time, there are no barriers, trains have a decent size height-wise,
trains run after snowfall, and I pay approx. 200 British pound for a full year of travel round the entire system with buses, trains, night buses and ferrys.

But not everything is perfect. Last October, rubbish left in a tunnel ignited and started a fire, in the process shorting all the power, signalling and telephone and data cables running in the tunnel, destroying one power substation and contaminating approx. 4 km of tunnel and three stations with toxic fumes and corrosive residue on every surface.

The tunnel reaching from just before Harburg to just after Heimfeld stations (this is on the most heavily used line outside the city centre) was closed for ten days while the cleaners cleaned every surface and the engineers bridged the power supply and overhauled the station lighting.

Then train service restarted (every ten minutes instead of the normal 5 minute service), without signalling, without passenger info displays, without station clocks, but this is not really necessary. Full service was reinstated at the end of November. (Comparing this to the central line crash which surely did less damage and was easier to repair)


:: TubeChallenge Homepage